PICO and Literature Search

CriteriaMasteryProficientDevelopingBeginningUnsatisfactoryCriterion ScorePICO question is properly formatted, per the EBP Step by Step 3 template.5 pointsyes4.5 points4 points3.5 points2.5 pointsnoScore of PICO question is properly formatted, per the EBP Step by Step 3 template.,/ 5All parts of the PICO are correctly identified for the question.10 points4 parts9 points3 parts8 points2 parts7 points1 part5 points0 partsScore of All parts of the PICO are correctly identified for the question.,/ 10All articles are primary source quantitative research reports20 points4 articles18 points3 articles16 points2 articles14 points1 article10 points0 articlesScore of All articles are primary source quantitative research reports,/ 20All articles help answer the same PICO question20 points4 articles18 points3 articles16 points2 articles14 points1 article10 points0 articlesScore of All articles help answer the same PICO question,/ 20Article citations in correct APA format10 pointsno unique errors9 points1 unique error8 points2 unique errors7 points3 unique errors6 points4 or more unique errorsScore of Article citations in correct APA format,/ 10Articles are no older than 2016 AND PDFs of all articles are provided3 pointsYes0 points0 points0 points0 pointsNoScore of Articles are no older than 2016 AND PDFs of all articles are provided,/ 3Rubric Total ScoreTotalScore of PICO and Literature Search Rubric,/ 68Overall ScoreOverall ScoreAdvanced63 points minimumProficient58 points minimumDeveloping51 points minimumBeginning41 points minimumUnsatisfactory40 points minimum